OK, I'll bite (so to speak!)
Seem's we are reducing the question to two variables:
How much does freezing pasta affect it. That's a good question, and I do not have enough experience/evidence to have an opinion on it. Because I trust your opinion on these things, I can surely *see* how freezing dough can adversely affect it.
The pasta I had at OVS was not especially good even though it was advertised as homemade. Now, I took it on face value that the pasta was homemade, ie. that the pasta was not purchased or produced elsewhere. But if the pasta was made in house, I saught to understand why exactly it was not particuliarly good and by that I mean, it did not taste very much like other home made pasta I have had. I reached a conclusion that it could be two possible factors: a) it was made using an extruder machine b) it was made in an Atlas machine. Now, I did not know the answer to my question, it was just guesses as why it did not taste true.
Now, you are contending that I would basically never be unhappy with pasta made on an Atlas machine or that with the pasta made on the Atlas machine, I would not notice a distinctly inferior quality. Or put another way, I think you contend that if OVS used an Atlas machine, I would not find the pasta so poor. Maybe you are right, maybe the poor pasta was not the result of the Atlas machine, but my gut sense is that it was and it is also my gut sense, as shown with the excerpt, that
some Italians find a real difference between hand rolled pasta and pasta made on an Atlas machine. Still, absent knowing the exact reason that produced the poor pasta at OVS, it's all speculatin'*
Rob
*And perhaps we should not rule out the idea that the pasta was not really house made.
Think Yiddish, Dress British - Advice of Evil Ronnie to me.