I did get to try Shabu-ya before it closed in Wrigleyville, and I didn't care for it. Even though I live near CoCoRo/East, I also have never ordered the Shabu-Shabu, probably because I haven't gone there with a group of people who really wanted to try it, nor have I been tempted to venture beyond the reasonably priced entrees where the marginal benefit does not outweigh the hefty price increase.
I would suggest for you to try the Chinese version of this at Lao Sze Chuan or Spring World, where I see it ordered much more often and prices are much more reasonable.
I really do wish there was a Shabu Tatsu in Chicago, a restaurant set up to handle groups of up to 10 people who all want Shabu-Shabu. Reasonable, great food, and a lot of fun.
Shabu Tatsu
1414 York Ave (at 75th)
New York, NY 10021
(212) 472-3322
there's food, and then there's food